“Achievements on the golf course are not what matters. Decency and honesty are what matter” – Tiger Woods
My first love was baseball. I stayed home as a kid in April 1977 to watch the first Toronto Blue Jays game on TV; mom new I wasn’t sick but she understood. The history, the seeming simplicity, the inherent challenge of hitting a round ball with a round bat. It’s a storytellers’ game, a game of eras where the greats of each generation stand as icons and heroes. I could go on and on. But this year, a cheating scandal came to light which, in my opinion, rivaled the Chicago Black Sox scandal of 1919. Unlike then, punishment was calculated, almost muted. The crux of my issue is punishment in sport needs to both penalize and deter. The Houston Astros, as of today, still retain their 2017 World Championship. And that is simply wrong. I don’t see how a systematic approach to cheating is no longer seen as a threat to the game, instead the threat is making sure you don’t get caught. But if so, meh. End justifies the means. It’s absurd. But what about golf?
“If we are to preserve the integrity of golf as left to us by our forefathers, it is up to all of us to carry on the true spirit of the game” – Ben Crenshaw
Enter Patrick Reed. The 2018 Masters Champion was caught on camera improving his lie in a bunker at the 2019 Hero Challenge. This galvanized a reputation for many based-on allegations as a college student at Augusta State. Recently, on the No Laying Up podcast, former CBS analyst Peter Kostis threw gasoline on the smoldering fire with comments alleging he saw Reed improve his lie on four separate occasions. If we assume Kostis is correct, we’re seeing the emergence of patterned behavior. And again, like the Houston Astros situation, penalties for Reed amounted to a light slap on the wrist, nothing close to a punishment with sufficient deterrent. Ask Lexi Thompson about the impact of penalties (see ANA Inspiration 2017).
“If there is one thing golf demands above all else, it is honesty” – Jack Nicklaus
I understand the principles of golf being unique in that players govern themselves. I understand, too, that golf is imperfect in its assessment of rules/penalties. Using the Thompson example, it boggles my mind how retroactive penalties can be imposed mid-round in a tournament. So perhaps that is not an ideal solution either. The facts are, blatant cheating, like we witnessed with Patrick Reed, has been left relatively unchecked. There is no real deterrent, in fact, the game of golf markets Reed’s villain status. So much for integrity and self-regulation. The images of Patrick Reed mimicking shoveling are the kind of things that should embarrass golf leadership into action, and not from their marketing/communications departments.
Fiery personalities? No problem. Brash and confident? Excellent. But there is a responsibility for players in golf to play with integrity. If there were more like Jason Millard, Ray Floyd of Brian Davis, the game would be in a better place. I admire the skill which Patrick Reed has. I loathe his lack of integrity and respect for the game. I am ashamed and embarrassed at the leadership in professional golf, and baseball, for being so tone deaf and seemingly unwilling to make a stand and demonstrate with strong action that actions like those of the Houston Astros, and Patrick Reed, will not be tolerated. Penalize. Deter. Maybe, and I acknowledge I am just spitballing here, the real hope here is Augusta National may take action, refusing Patrick to don the green jacket moving forward. The leadership void in sports these days confuses me.
Absent any true leadership, I am going to seek out and celebrate stories of those who put the game before themselves. To me, it is one the defining assets in the game of golf.
2 thoughts on “Cheating in Sport (including golf)”
I like the fiery article. I agree on many levels that there needs to be some sort of leadership within the golfing community to address the cheating. I have a couple of things that I would like to bring up:
First, retroactive penalties should go by the way side. Especially ones that are assessed through video replay. This leads to my next point.
Second, the players themselves need to take more responsibility in calling penalties at the time they happen. There is no way that all of Reid’s playing partners did not notice his indiscretions. So, they should step up and call him out right then and there.
Third, we all talk about integrity. I think it is important to tie it with intent. The difference between Lexi and Patrick is intent. Lexi, in my opinion, did not intend to break the rules. I cannot say the same for Patrick. Regardless, intent and integrity have to be talked about in the same breath.
With respect to golf, we have penalties for breaking the rules. If these additional strokes were awarded at the right time by all the players, it will hurt the offending players most…..in their pockets. They will be out of the money so much that they would start thinking twice about intentionally breaking the rules.
With havin so much written content do you ever run into any issues of plagorism
or copyright violation? My blog has a lot of exclusive content
I’ve either created myself or outsourced but it appears a lot of it is popping it up
all over the web without my authorization. Do you know any
techniques to help stop content from being stolen? I’d
truly appreciate it.
Comments are closed.